Comparison
Two switches and a five-year warranty against a thermal carafe, a timer and a saved recipe. Which one fits depends on how long your coffee sits.
Our pick
Editor’s pick
9.5/10
Buy this one if you want a machine you’ll never replace. Holds 196–205°F, has two controls that can’t be set wrong, and carries a five-year warranty with lifetime repairs.
Around $370
The alternative
9/10
Buy this one if your coffee sits, or you want it ready when you wake. A thermal carafe Breville rates above 150°F for four hours, a 24-hour timer and a cold brew preset.
Around $330
| Moccamaster KBGV | Breville Luxe Brewer | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | ||
| What it is | Fixed-recipe drip brewer: two switches | Programmable drip brewer: one button or a saved recipe |
| Price | ||
| Price | Around $370 | Around $330 |
| SCA certified | ||
| SCA certified | Yes (also ECBC) | Yes |
| Brew temp | ||
| Brew temp | Fixed 196–205°F, copper element | Adjustable in Custom Brew |
| Custom settings | ||
| Custom settings | None | One saved profile: bloom volume, bloom time, temp, flow |
| Carafe | ||
| Carafe | 40oz glass on a hotplate | Dual-wall thermal, above 150°F for 4 hours |
| Water tank | ||
| Water tank | Fixed | Removable 60oz, Claro Swiss filter |
| Programmable timer | ||
| Programmable timer | No | Up to 24 hours ahead |
| Cold brew | ||
| Cold brew | No | Preset, up to 30 minutes |
| Filter baskets | ||
| Filter baskets | One | Cone and flat-bottom, both included |
| Warranty | ||
| Warranty | 5 years, lifetime repairs | Not stated on the Amazon listing |
| Track record | ||
| Track record | Decades; owners run 15-year-old units | New, few long-term owner reports |
The Luxe wins most rows and the Moccamaster is still the pick. The Luxe’s wins are features you use daily if your coffee sits; the Moccamaster’s two are what decide whether you’re buying another machine in five years.
Around $370
Around $330
If you want the Moccamaster with a thermal carafe
Technivorm makes one, the KBGT, so the carafe alone isn’t a reason to switch brands. Thermal machines we rank, the Luxe included, are in the best thermal carafe coffee makers.
If you’re weighing the Precision Brewer too
The Luxe is Breville’s newer machine with the Precision Brewer’s controls and a removable tank. The older machine has six brew modes against the Moccamaster in Moccamaster vs Breville Precision Brewer.
For most households, the Moccamaster. Brewed at their defaults, both target the same 196–205°F Golden Cup window, so the cup won’t separate them. The Moccamaster is the better machine to own: ECBC certified as well as SCA, a five-year warranty with lifetime repairs, and decades of owners running the same unit. The Luxe is the better machine to live with if your coffee sits or you want it on a timer: a thermal carafe rated above 150°F for four hours, a removable 60oz tank with a filter, a 24-hour delayed start and a cold brew preset.
The Moccamaster has one fixed recipe, two controls, a 40oz glass carafe on a hotplate and a fixed tank. The Breville Luxe Brewer has a one-touch Golden Cup mode plus one saved custom profile for bloom volume, bloom time, temperature and flow rate, a dual-wall thermal carafe, a removable 60oz tank with a Claro Swiss filter, cone and flat-bottom baskets, a 24-hour timer and a cold brew preset. The Moccamaster is hand-assembled in the Netherlands with a five-year warranty and lifetime repairs; the Luxe’s Amazon listing doesn’t state a warranty term.
The Breville Luxe. Its dual-wall thermal carafe is rated above 150°F for up to four hours and doesn’t keep heating the coffee. The Moccamaster KBGV keeps its glass carafe hot on a hotplate that shuts off after 100 minutes, and a hotplate keeps coffee hot by continuing to cook it, so a pot that sits an hour tastes worse than it did at minute five. Technivorm’s KBGT is the Moccamaster with a thermal carafe.
The Moccamaster, on the evidence that exists. It carries a five-year warranty with lifetime repair support, every part is user-replaceable, and owners run fifteen-year-old units on replacement elements. The Luxe is new enough that there are few long-term owner reports, its Amazon listing doesn’t state a warranty term, and its adjustable controls, timer and cold brew cycle are more electronics to go wrong over a decade.
The Breville Luxe has a cold brew preset that brews at a higher concentration and is ready in up to 30 minutes, depending on volume. The Moccamaster brews hot coffee only. A fast cold brew cycle isn’t the same as an overnight steep, so treat it as a useful extra rather than a reason to buy.
Neither. The Moccamaster runs 92–96°C water through a polypropylene basket and outlet arm, and Breville doesn’t publish the materials in the Luxe’s brew path. If that’s the deciding factor, Simply Good Coffee’s Brewer is the automatic with steel and glass through the whole hot path, compared against the Moccamaster on its own page.
Neither one?
If plastic is the real question, see Simply Good Coffee vs Moccamaster. If you want more control than either, there’s Moccamaster vs Fellow Aiden, and the rest of the field is in Moccamaster alternatives.
New gear reviews, brew tips, and the occasional deal — straight to your inbox. No spam, ever.
Just your email, nothing else. Privacy